I am in the middle of a bit of an uncomfortable situation at the moment. I know that others would think nothing of it, but since I am extremely anti-confrontation, and this situation involves a bit of confrontation, I squirm just to think about it, and I am loathe to see it resolved properly - I just want to let it all blow over.
The situation is about Christian Parenting. The problem is; I don't think Christian parenting exists. Christian parents, yes. Parenting based on broad Christian principles and attitudes, yes. Christian parenting, no. You may think I am just playing with semantics here, but the implications of the subtle difference in phrasing are quite significant.
Christian parenting tries to tell me that there is a clear, God-ordained method by which I should be raising my children. Christian parenting books use a confusing mix of random out-of-context Bible verses, some truthful biblical ideas, some human wisdom dressed up as biblical wisdom, some case studies and some nifty tips. They try to convince me that God gives me specifics about how to raise my children his way. They try to convince me that every other way is wrong. They tell me what my itching ears want to hear. Of course I want to hear that I just do x + y + z and my children will turn out to be mature Christians, well-rounded, contributing members of society. Guaranteed.
The problem is that the Bible is not that specific about parenting. The Bible is God's story about how he reveals himself through history, and saves his people through Jesus. It is not my story about how I parent my children.
The Bible is not irrelevant in parenting. It is highly relevant. The Bible tells me how God deals with his people as a Father. God's fatherhood is grace, and truth, and love, and compassion, and sacrifice, and forgiveness, and gentleness, and patience, and justice and... (
See this post for some Bible references). The Bible instructs me about how I am to relate to others with grace, and truth, and love, and compassion, and sacrifice, and forgiveness, and gentleness, and patience, and justice, and... The Bible establishes the order of God's creation, reminding me that God is to be my ruler, that my marriage relationship comes second and my children come third (Genesis chapter 2-3). This has huge implications for parenting. The Bible reminds me that Jesus is coming again, and that I have a role to see that my children know and trust Jesus (Revelation 22:7). The Bible tells me to train my children in the way they should go (Proverbs 22:6). The Bible urges me to pray without ceasing (1 Thessalonians 5:17)... and this includes prayer for my children. The Bible tells me to be light and salt to the world (Matthew 5:13-16) - including living as a witness to my children.
But, the Bible does
not give me any specific instruction on sleep (routines, co-sleeping), or on feeding (bottle or breast - and for how long?), or on methods of discipline (rewards, punishment, time-out, smacking - apart from a widely disagreed upon Proverbs 13:24). The Bible does not talk about spending one-to-one time with each child, or teaching children to play on their own, or the
balance between structured and unstructured play. It doesn't address pocket money, or promoting early learning, or appropriate types of toys, or
how much TV our kids should watch. It doesn't even talk about the importance of consistency, or the distinction between childishness and disobedience, or
how to really love your child.
I am not bagging any of these things of course (one look at the topic menu on my blog would reveal that I love talking about this stuff!). There is a lot of wisdom to be found in parenting books and ideas. There is a lot of wisdom to be found in parenting books/ courses/ ideas that are promoted as Christian.
But there is a danger when the distinction between what the Bible says and what are just good ideas is not made clear. There is a danger when mums and dads are made to feel that they are not parenting "God's way" because they want to sleep in the same bed with their children. Or because they don't want to sleep with their children. Or because they choose not to smack their children. Or because they choose to smack their children. Or because they let their children watch 3 hours of TV per day. Or...
I have a friend who was a relatively new Christian. After reading one Christian parenting book, trying to implement it to the letter, and failing dismally (much of it was just inappropriate for her own personality and that of her daughter), she began to question her worth as a parent. She even began to question whether she was in fact a Christian! I cannot even express how much this grieves me. To think that there may be Christians who doubt their very salvation over an extreme case of mother-guilt (brought on by over-zealous "Christian" parenting instructions). I don't even want to think that there may be parents who are turned away from getting to know the true Jesus because they don't like the parenting style that his followers espouse as being "God's way".
What do you think? Has the Christian parenting movement gone too far?